Description of Comerica Securities, Inc.
Comerica Securities, Inc. (“Comerica Securities”) is a non-bank affiliate of Comerica, Inc.
(“Comerica”) and a part of Comerica’s Wealth Management Division (“WM”). Comerica’s Wealth
Management team consists of various divisions of Comerica Bank, affiliates of Comerica Bank
including Comerica Bank & Trust N.A., and subsidiaries of Comerica Bank, including Comerica
Securities, Inc., and Comerica Insurance Services, Inc. and its affiliated insurance agencies
(“CIS”). Also under the WM umbrella is Comerica Asset Management (“CAM”), an unincorporated
division. Comerica Securities was formed in 1985 and became a Securities and Exchange
Commission (“SEC”) registered investment adviser in 2005. Comerica Securities is 100% owned
by Comerica Investment Services, which is 100% owned by Comerica Bank, which is 100%
owned by Comerica, Inc., a publicly traded company. Comerica Securities is a member of the
Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc. (“FINRA”) and the Securities Investor Protection
Corporation (“SIPC”).
Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended, and the Internal Revenue
Code of 1986, as amended
When we provide investment advice to you regarding your retirement plan account or individual
retirement account, we are fiduciaries within the meaning of Title I of the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (“ERISA”) and/or the Internal Revenue Code of 1986,
as amended (“IRC”), as applicable, which are laws governing retirement accounts. The way we
make money creates some conflicts with your interests, so we operate under a special rule that
requires us to act in your best interest and not put our interest ahead of yours.
Under this special rule’s provisions, we must:
• Meet a professional standard of care when making investment
recommendations (give prudent advice);
• Never put our financial interests ahead of yours when making
recommendations (give loyal advice);
• Avoid misleading statements about conflicts of interest, fees, and
investments;
• Follow policies and procedures designed to ensure that we give
advice that is in your best interest;
• Charge no more than is reasonable for our services; and
• Give you basic information about conflicts of interest.
When providing recommendations to retirement plan accounts involving rollover considerations,
there are generally four options regarding an existing retirement plan account. An employee may
use a combination of those options, such as; (i) leave the funds in the former employer’s plan, if
permitted, (ii) roll over the funds to a new employer’s plan, if one is available and rollovers are
permitted, (iii) roll over to an Individual Retirement Account (“IRA”), or (iv) cash out the account
value (which could, depending upon the individual’s age, result in adverse tax consequences). If
your Financial Consultant recommends that you rollover your retirement plan and/or transfer IRA
assets into an account managed by Comerica Securities, such recommendation creates a conflict
of interest insofar as we will earn an advisory fee on the rolled over or transferred assets.
A. Wrap Program Services
Managed Portfolio Solutions (“MPS”), the wrap fee program sponsored by Comerica Securities
(the “Adviser”), provides both discretionary and non-discretionary investment advisory services
as described in this brochure. The Comerica Securities MPS Program includes the Personal
Portfolio Advisory, Comerica Managed Portfolios, Fund Strategist Portfolios, Separately Managed
Account, Unified Managed Account programs, and the Envestnet Impact and Tax Overlay
Services. The MPS Program utilizes Envestnet Asset Management, Inc. (“Envestnet”), a
registered investment adviser, as the Platform Manager and as a Consultant. The Platform
Manager operates the technology platform on which the wrap program functions and provides
certain investment advisory services to Adviser and Adviser’s clients. Envestnet’s portfolio
consulting group, Portfolio Management Consultants (“PMC”), conducts research on asset
managers and investment vehicles, provides consultation to the Adviser regarding investment
selection and acts as an Overlay Manager for certain programs. Envestnet and Adviser are not
affiliated other than through jointly providing services to the wrap fee program.
As explained above, Comerica Securities, through common control and ownership, is an affiliate
of CAM. CAM provides certain investment management strategy and model services to Comerica
Securities, which are made available for investment as part of its wrap fee program.
All accounts participating in the MPS Program are held in custody at our clearing firm, Pershing
LLC (“Pershing”).
Managed Portfolio Solutions Program
Fees for the MPS Program are described below. Fees are negotiable and discounts on fees are
available based on, but not limited to, the household relationship with Comerica Securities and
amount of assets under management. Additionally, Program Accounts may be on a fee schedule
that is no longer offered. As a result, clients with similar assets will have differing fee schedules.
The Firm generally does not permit clients to hold non-advisory assets (i.e., non-Program Assets)
in their Program Accounts. If the Firm agrees to do so, these assets will be deemed to be
“Unsupervised Assets” (i.e., assets for which you will not receive investment advice).
Unsupervised Assets are excluded from the Client Fee calculation. Unsupervised Assets are also
excluded from Program Account performance calculations, including performance reports created
by the Platform Manager.
The fee you pay will change over time due to the investments chosen, the effects of market
conditions, and investment performance on your account asset value. Any additions or
withdrawals made in your account will also affect the fee you pay. Any fees you pay reduce the
overall value of and net performance of your Program Account. You should consider the
aggregate costs and expenses of investment advisory services and products as a whole.
For all MPS Program Accounts, in addition to the Client Fees, clients will also pay management
fees and expenses to mutual funds and ETFs when utilized in their portfolio. Mutual fund trades
are executed as “no load” (without commissions or sales charges). Please refer to “General
Information on Fees” and “Client Fees” for additional information.
Personal Portfolio Advisory (“PPA”)
For clients in this program, a Comerica Securities Financial Consultant (hereafter, “Financial
Consultant”) will construct, through the use of asset allocation software, allocation models based
on specific client investment objectives and risk tolerances. The Financial Consultant will then
recommend various investment choices based on asset class to populate the proposed allocation
model. These recommendations can include, but are not limited to, common and preferred
equities, mutual funds, exchange-traded -funds, and fixed-income securities. You will be
presented with the proposed allocation model and investment recommendations to review prior
to establishing an account. If you choose to execute the proposed model, the account will be
established on a fully discretionary basis.
Non-discretionary Personal Portfolio Advisory (“PPA”) accounts are no longer offered. For
existing non-discretionary PPA accounts, the Financial Consultant will not be acting in a
discretionary manner nor will the Financial Consultant make any investment decisions without
your consent. The Financial Consultant will periodically evaluate the portfolio while taking into
account changing economic and market conditions as well as changes to your personal financial
situation. When deemed appropriate by your Financial Consultant, recommendations for
rebalancing or re-allocation will be made to you. Your Financial Consultant will review your
account allocations with you as necessary but no less than annually.
For discretionary accounts, the investments used to populate your model will be selected by the
Financial Consultant and managed (e.g., bought and sold) by him or her as necessary to meet
changing economic and market conditions as well as your personal financial situation. The
Financial Consultant’s use of discretion can include, but is not limited to, the purchase, sale or
other disposition of securities (i.e., Program Assets) within your Program Account. This includes,
for example, the exchange or tender of shares as part of a corporate action. Your Financial
Consultant will rebalance your account allocations as he or she deems necessary; accounts are
typically rebalanced no less than annually.
If a client accepts the proposal, the client will receive an Investment Policy Statement that also
contains Managed Portfolio Solutions Terms & Conditions. The minimum initial investment for the
PPA program is $50,000. The Fee Schedule for the PPA Program is as follows:
Fee Schedule
Assets Managed Advisor Fee
On first $2 Million 1.35%
On next $3 Million 0.90%
On next $5 Million 0.60%
On Balance (>$10 Million) 0.40%
For all PPA accounts, the Client Fee will include an Advisor Fee and an Overlay Fee. Advisor
Fees are charged by Comerica Securities for investment advisory services provided, including
but not limited to investment management services. The Overlay Fee represents the costs
associated with account oversight and investment management by your Financial Consultant as
the Portfolio Manager. This includes, for example, model management and portfolio rebalancing.
The Overlay Fee is 0.10% and will be assessed against total Program Assets. The Advisor Fee
and Overlay Fee are considered compensation paid to Comerica and your Financial Consultant.
Comerica Managed Portfolios
The Comerica Managed Portfolios (“CMP”) program provides clients with access to portfolio
solutions designed to help them meet their investment goals. CMP solutions utilize various
approaches to asset allocation and model construction. CMP strategies and models are provided
by CAM.
CMPs can employ a longer-term, strategic asset allocation approach, or take a dynamic or tactical
approach, which more actively adjusts allocations in an attempt to take advantage of intermediate
or shorter-term market movements. The CMP program can provide unique solutions across
traditional asset classes, specific countries or regions, different sectors (domestic and non-U.S.),
alternatives, and/or commodities, that are designed to fit a range of risk profiles and objectives.
The models and strategies offered generally range from solutions for the conservative investor to
those with a high-risk tolerance seeking maximum growth potential.
The CMPs generally use exchange traded funds (“ETFs”), mutual funds and/or Separately
Managed Accounts (“SMAs”), including those managed by Envestnet Asset Management’s
(“Envestnet”) Portfolio Management Consulting (“PMC”) group. The CMP program asset
allocation model or strategy recommended to you, along with any other products or securities
chosen for your overall model (portfolio), if any, will be determined by your individual responses
to a risk tolerance questionnaire.
Tax-sensitive strategies and tax-managed models are available in CMP models and certain risk
regions. Tax-sensitive strategies typically include the use of tax-exempt fixed-income mutual
funds and ETFs and/or SMAs in their fixed-income allocations.
PMC provides services related to the products chosen to populate asset allocation models for all
CMP strategies (Premier and Select). A comprehensive due diligence process incorporating
quantitative, qualitative and fundamental analysis seeks to identify products expected to add a
higher level of risk adjusted performance over time to each client’s specific asset allocation. CAM
periodically reviews and monitors the products and allocations in its models and makes changes
when deemed warranted. The addition (or removal) of an SMA Manager will increase (or
decrease) your Client Fee. (For additional details, please see the fee information beginning on
page 13 of this brochure.) CAM’s process provides the benefits of diversification, appropriate
asset class exposure, passive and active investment management. CAM strategies do not
undergo the same due diligence process and analysis that non-proprietary strategies do.
Trades in CMP Program Accounts are placed on a discretionary basis. The models in the CMP
program can be rebalanced when an investment change is made or upon certain deposits or
withdrawals of funds. A rebalance could result in a buy or sell of securities held in a Program
Account. Additionally, clients can choose from three different rebalance schedules to better suit
their investment preferences. Reviews and the monitoring process for these accounts follows a
disciplined methodology emphasizing proper asset allocation and product selection for each of
the models.
If a client accepts the proposal, the client will receive an Investment Policy Statement that also
contains the Managed Portfolio Solutions Program Terms and Conditions. The minimum initial
investment for the CMP program is determined by the product selection but will be no less than
$50,000. Minimums can be substantially higher depending on the client’s model and managers
selected.
The Fee Schedule for the Comerica Managed Portfolios Program is listed on page 12.
Fund Strategist Portfolios
The Fund Strategist Portfolios (“FSP”) program provides clients with access to investment
strategists who construct portfolio solutions designed to help them meet their investment goals.
FSP solutions utilize various approaches to asset allocation and model construction. FSP
strategies and models are provided by CAM and by non-affiliated third-party model providers.
FSPs can employ a longer-term, strategic asset allocation approach, or take a dynamic or tactical
approach, which more actively adjusts allocations in an attempt to take advantage of intermediate
or shorter-term market movements. The FSP program can provide unique solutions across
traditional asset classes, specific countries or regions, different sectors (domestic and non-U.S.),
alternatives, and/or commodities, that are designed to fit a range of risk profiles and objectives.
The models and strategies offered in the FSP program generally range from solutions for the
conservative investor to those with a high-risk tolerance seeking maximum growth potential.
Portfolio solutions from certain model providers are available only in select risk ranges.
FSPs generally use actively managed mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (“ETFs”) and/or
exchange-traded notes (“ETNs”) in their models or strategies. The FSP program asset allocation
model or strategy recommended to you, along with any other products or securities chosen for
your overall model (portfolio), if any, will be determined by your individual responses to a risk
tolerance questionnaire.
Tax-sensitive strategies and tax-managed models are available in certain FSP models and certain
risk regions. Tax-sensitive strategies typically include the use of tax-exempt fixed-income mutual
funds and ETFs in their fixed-income allocations. Tax-managed models have a goal of providing
improved after-tax returns using mutual funds that employ various tax-managed and tax-
harvesting strategies.
Risk Tolerance and Model Target Risk Scoring
Each FSP model is assigned a target risk score that aligns with a specific risk tolerance ranging
from: capital preservation; conservative; moderate; growth; to aggressive growth. For CAM
provided models, the target risk score is assigned based on the model’s current asset allocation.
For all other FSPs, the target risk score is assigned by PMC and is set at the maximum risk score
a strategy could have based on the strategist’s asset allocation policies. As a result, the current
allocation and investment holdings in a client’s model can score more conservatively than the
maximum risk score PMC has assigned to the portfolio and result in a client being invested in an
asset allocation model which is in a lower risk range/tolerance than was determined by the client’s
risk tolerance questionnaire.
For the FSPs provided by CAM (Alpha Fund Advisory, Comerica Index, and Comerica
Dimensional Portfolios), PMC provides services related to the products chosen to populate asset
allocation models. CAM strategies do not undergo the same due diligence process and analysis
that non-proprietary strategies do. A comprehensive due diligence process incorporating
quantitative, qualitative and fundamental analysis seeks to identify mutual funds (in the case of
Alpha Fund Advisory and Comerica Dimensional Portfolios) expected to add a higher level of risk
adjusted performance over time to each client’s specific asset allocation. The Comerica Index
models currently utilize only ETFs. Comerica Dimensional Portfolio FSP models utilize only open-
end mutual funds managed by Dimensional Fund Advisors (“DFA”). DFA can also, from time to
time, provide information to CAM related to the funds chosen to populate these models.
CAM periodically reviews and monitors the products and allocations in its FSP models and makes
changes when deemed warranted. CAM’s process provides the benefits of diversification and
active investment management (in the case of Alpha Fund Advisory and Comerica Dimensional
Portfolios) and diversification and appropriate asset class exposure (in the case of Comerica
Index).
The models in the FSP program can be rebalanced when an investment change is made or upon
certain deposits or withdrawals of funds. Additionally, clients can choose from three different
rebalance schedules to better suit their investment preferences. Reviews and the monitoring
process for these accounts follows a disciplined methodology emphasizing proper asset allocation
and product selection for each of the models. Trades in all FSP Program Accounts are placed on
a discretionary basis.
If a client accepts the proposal, the client will receive an Investment Policy Statement that also
contains the Managed Portfolio Solutions Program Terms and Conditions. The minimum initial
investment in the FSP program is $25,000.
The Fee Schedule for the Fund Strategist Portfolios Program is listed on page 12.
Separately Managed Account (“SMA”)
For clients with SMA accounts, Envestnet’s portfolio consulting group, PMC will recommend a list
of individual asset managers (“managers”), mutual funds and exchange traded funds that
correspond to the proposed asset classes and styles displayed in the asset allocation model
constructed by your Financial Consultant. The asset allocation model is derived from specific
client responses to the client questionnaire. Comerica Securities, as part of the proposal process,
will recommend specific managers, mutual funds or ETFs from this list.
The managers and mutual funds selected to participate in the SMA program are chosen after an
intensive evaluation and due diligence process conducted by PMC. This due diligence process
focuses on quantitative and qualitative factors such as the manager’s and investment vehicle’s
reputation, approach to investing, and style consistency.
If a client accepts the proposal, the client will receive an Investment Policy Statement that also
contains the Managed Portfolio Solutions Program Terms and Conditions. The minimum initial
investment for these accounts is $100,000. Minimums can be higher depending on the manager
selected. The Fee Schedule for the Separately Managed Account Program is listed on page 12.
Unified Managed Account (“UMA”)
For clients with UMA accounts, Financial Consultants will have access to an approved list of SMA
Model Managers, mutual funds, and ETFs that have undergone PMC’s due diligence process.
This includes certain strategies provided by CAM and those provided by non-affiliated third-party
managers. CAM strategies include certain strategies provided in the Fund Strategist Portfolios
program. CAM strategies do not undergo the same due diligence process and analysis that non-
proprietary strategies do. SMA strategies provided by PMC are also available in UMA.
A Financial Consultant will construct a portfolio in a single account for the client that can be
comprised of a combination of manager models, mutual funds and/or ETFs in custom “sleeves.”
From time to time, as they deem necessary, CAM and other managers will make changes to their
models based on current market and economic conditions. The UMA track is not expected to be
an exact replica of a separately managed account for any model because UMA accounts can
utilize several manager portfolio models in a single account. Financial Consultants can also utilize
a sleeve(s) comprised of a model(s) that he or she constructed in the PPA Program. PPA models
can include investments such as individual stocks and bonds, as well as access to a broader
menu of mutual funds and ETFs that are not typically available in the UMA Program.
Your account can be established on either a non-discretionary basis or a fully discretionary basis
with investment discretion granted to your Financial Consultant.
If you choose to open a non-discretionary account, the Financial Consultant will not be acting in
a discretionary manner, nor will the Financial Consultant make any investment decisions without
your consent. The Financial Consultant will periodically evaluate the portfolio while taking into
account changing economic and market conditions as well as changes to your personal financial
situation. When deemed appropriate by your Financial Consultant, recommendations for
rebalancing or reallocation will be made to you. Your Financial Consultant will review your account
allocations as necessary, but no less than annually.
If you choose to open a fully discretionary account, investments used to populate portfolio sleeves
will be selected by the Financial Consultant and managed by him or her as necessary to meet
changing economic and market conditions as well as your personal financial situation. The
Financial Consultant’s use of discretion can include the purchase, sale or other disposition of
individual securities, SMA Managers and Fund Strategists (i.e., Program Assets) within your
Program Account.
The addition (or removal) of an SMA Manager and certain Fund Strategists will increase (or
decrease) your Client Fee. (For additional details regarding SMA fees, please see the fee
information beginning on page 13 of this brochure.) Discretion can also include, for example, the
exchange or tender of shares as part of a corporate action. Your Financial Consultant can also
reallocate portfolio holdings, within your chosen risk tolerance, and will rebalance your account
allocations as necessary, but generally no less than annually.
Additionally, the UMA account utilizes Envestnet a-s an Overlay Manager who coordinates trading
across sleeves in a “multi-sleeve” portfolio. The Overlay Manager can, without prior consultation,
buy, sell, exchange, convert and otherwise trade in securities as directed by a separate account
manager, model provider or investment management strategy and consistent with the direction in
your Investment Policy Statement.
The managers and investments selected to participate in the UMA program are chosen after an
intensive evaluation and due diligence process conducted by PMC. This due diligence process
focuses on quantitative and qualitative factors such as the manager’s and investment vehicle’s
reputation, approach to investing, and style consistency. Investments selected by a Financial
Consultant in any PPA model(s) utilized in the UMA program are typically not reviewed by PMC.
The Fee Schedule for the Comerica Managed Portfolios, Fund Strategist Portfolios, Separately
Managed Account, and Unified Managed Account Program is as follows:
Fee Schedule
Assets Managed Advisor Fee
On first $2 Million 1.35%
On next $3 Million 0.90%
On next $5 Million 0.60%
On Balance (>$10 Million) 0.40%
For all CMP, FSP, SMA, and UMA accounts, the Client Fee will include an Advisor Fee and, when
applicable, a Manager Fee and a SMA Platform Fee. When an SMA Manager(s) is included as
part of a portfolio, a Manager Fee will be added to the Advisor Fee paid by the client. Certain
FSPs can also be subject to a Manager Fee. Manager Fees are only assessed against the portion
of Program Assets managed by the SMA Manager(s). Manager Fees vary based on the SMA
Manager or FSP Strategy selected and range from 0.0% to 0.50%. This range can change due
to the addition or removal of available SMA Managers or FSP Strategies.
The SMA Platform Fee, which is assessed by Envestnet is included in the Manager Fee (i.e., the
range cited above). The SMA Platform Fee varies based on the SMA Manager(s) or FSP Strategy
selected and ranges from 0.0% to 0.02%. The Client Fee paid is the sum of the Advisor Fee and
Manager Fee, when applicable.
Fixed Income Models (PPA, SMA, and UMA Programs Only)
Certain Program Accounts may be eligible for a Fixed Income Model Advisor Fee Schedule. To
qualify, a Program Account’s initial model allocation must generally be allocated 95% (or more)
to Fixed Income Securities, as defined by Envestnet. Fixed Income Securities include individual
bonds, and certain exchange traded funds and open-end mutual funds. If, after a Program
Account is deemed eligible and the Program Account’s Fixed Income Model allocation
subsequently falls below 95% due to position drift (i.e., Program Asset value increases or
decreases relative to its target allocation), the Program Account will remain eligible for the Fixed
Income Model Advisor Fee Schedule. However, if a client makes changes to their model
allocation, such that allocation to Fixed Income Securities falls below 95%, then a goal
modification will be required and the standard (i.e., non-Fixed Income Model) Advisor Fee
Schedule for the applicable program will apply.
The Client Fee paid for Fixed Income models in the PPA Program will be the sum of the Fixed
Income Model Advisor Fee and Overlay Fee as described in the Fee Schedule information in the
Personal Portfolio Advisory (PPA) section above. The Client Fee paid for Fixed Income models
in the UMA and SMA Programs will be the sum of the Fixed Income Model Advisor Fee and, if
applicable, SMA Platform Fee and Manager Fee as described in Fee Schedule information in the
Unified Managed Account section above. Clients who elect to enroll in any Envestnet Impact and
Tax Overlay services will also pay an Overlay Fee in UMA.
The Fee Schedule for the Fixed Income Models is as follows:
Advisor Fee Schedule:
Assets Managed Advisor Fee
On first $2 Million 0.50%
On next $3 Million 0.35%
On next $5 Million 0.25%
On next $10 Million 0.20%
On balance >$20 Million 0.15%
Envestnet Impact and Tax Overlay Services
Envestnet Impact and Tax Overlay Services (“tax services”) are provided by Envestnet. For
Program Accounts enrolled in the services, Envestnet will provide discretionary investment advice
through overlay portfolio management services and tax overlay management services.
Tax services are not suitable for all clients and are not intended to be general tax planning
services. Tax services can be appropriate for clients
who, for example, want to limit net long-term
or short-term gains, who own “appreciated securities” (i.e., securities with a low cost basis) and
want to manage how gains are realized for selling these securities, who are be subject to the
Alternative Minimum Tax, or those clients who specifically budget for taxes associated with their
Program Account(s).
Envestnet relies solely on the tax information provided by the client. To the extent such information
is inaccurate or incomplete, the tax strategy developed for the client can be adversely affected.
The provision of complete and accurate tax information is the sole responsibility of the client.
The use of the tax services can result in recommendations from Envestnet that differ from those
made by the Adviser and/or can be inconsistent with the client’s chosen investment model and
strategy. This can cause trading, holdings and/or performance of the client’s portfolio to deviate
from a portfolio that does not apply these services. Additionally, the use of these services can
cause the client’s account risk to differ from the risk profile identified for the client during the
proposal process.
In order to enroll in the tax services, clients must complete an Envestnet Tax Overlay Services
questionnaire. Clients should consult with their tax and legal advisors regarding their specific
situation prior to completing the form or enrolling. Comerica Securities does not provide tax or
legal advice.
The tax services can be used individually, or in combination with the other services. They can
only be selected in conjunction with UMA portfolios. The minimum Program Account size for these
tax services is $250,000. For additional information regarding the individual services, please refer
to the sections below. The Fee Schedule for these services is listed below on page 15.
Envestnet Impact Overlay Services
This service allows clients to apply customized socially responsible investment (“Impact”)
restrictions to their investment portfolio. These restrictions are designed for investors who are
willing to allow some deviation from their selected portfolios in an aim to minimize their exposure
to companies with specific products, services, and operations that do not meet the client’s values
and personal convictions. The overlay service leverages software that applies predefined screens
and rules to help keep the client’s Impact-screened portfolio reasonably close to the model
portfolio recommended by the Financial Consultant.
Envestnet Tax Overlay Services
These services offer clients a premium solution to help limit long-term gains, short-term gains
and/or to attempt to limit their potential tax liabilities. It also offers more customizable solutions
for clients who are seeking to attempt to control the realization of large unrealized gains that are
imbedded in their portfolios.
These services allow clients to have their Program Account traded with tax-aware portfolio
management techniques by leveraging software that applies predefined rules and constraints to
help keep the client’s tax-aware portfolio reasonably close to the model portfolio recommended
by their Financial Consultant. The software seeks to consider the tax costs of trading that detract
from the client’s after-tax returns. This service is designed for taxable investors who are willing
to allow some deviation from their selected portfolios in an aim to minimize the impact of taxes on
their returns by attempting to match capital gains with capital losses during a given tax year.
Clients that have other unique tax circumstances that require an individualized strategy may also
benefit from the services. If these services are selected by the client, the Financial Consultant,
working with Envestnet, will determine an appropriate asset allocation and model to establish the
tax management goals desired for the client’s Program Account.
Envestnet Impact and Tax Overlay Services Fee Schedule
Assets Managed Overlay Fee
On first $10 Million 0.16%
On next $15 Million 0.13%
On Balance >$25 Million 0.09%
For CMP and UMA clients who elect to utilize these services, the Client Fee will be the sum of
the Advisor Fee, the Overlay Fee and, when applicable, a Manager Fee.
For additional details regarding the Manager Fee, CMP Program fee and the UMA Program Fee
Schedule, please refer to the Section Item 4. Services, Fees and Compensation above.
Personal Portfolio Advisory, Comerica Managed Portfolios, Fund Strategist Portfolios,
Separately Managed Account, Unified Managed Account and Envestnet Impact, and Tax
Overlay Service Client Fees
Client will pay a Client Fee calculated by applying the annual fee percentage as provided (the
“Fee Schedule”) in the program descriptions. This fee will be applied to the asset value of the
assets held in the Program Accounts. The initial Client Fee will equal (on an annualized basis)
the percentage as set forth in the Fee Schedule of the fair market value of the client’s Program
Assets. Client authorizes and directs Comerica Securities to instruct Pershing to deduct from
Program Accounts such Client Fees as are due. Pershing shall retain the custodial fee due them
in connection with the Program and shall disburse the remainder of the Client Fee to Adviser and
to Platform Manager in accordance with the Adviser’s instructions. Platform Manager shall retain
or distribute to any investment model portfolio managers (“Model Provider”) and any third-party
service providers any amounts due such parties in connection with the Programs. Some Program
Accounts may be on a fee schedule that is no longer offered, or may have a fee discount due to
a householding arrangement. As a result, clients with similar assets will have differing fee
schedules.
The Advisor Fee and (PPA) Overlay Fee portions of the Client Fee received from Program
Accounts is considered compensation paid to Comerica Securities and to its Financial
Consultants. A portion of the Client Fees paid by you can be shared with Comerica Securities
employees who do not provide investment advice or other advisory services for your Program
Account. This include individuals in administrative roles or those based on certain partnership
arrangements with a Financial Consultant(s).
For the Managed Portfolio Solutions Program, the Platform Manager may receive an SMA
Platform Fee ranging from 0.0% to 0.02%. The SMA Platform Fee is only applicable when certain
SMA or FSP Manager(s) are included in the client’s Program Account.
A portion of the Client Fee, ranging from 0.0% to 0.50%, will be paid out to a separate asset
manager(s), as applicable. This range may change due to the addition or removal of available
SMA Managers, FSP Strategies and other model or strategy providers.
Your Client Fee will be deducted directly from your Program Account. The initial Client Fee for
the first calendar month (or part thereof) in which the client participates in the Program shall be
calculated and debited on or before the 15th day of the month (or the next business day if the
15th is a non-business day) after initial Program Assets are placed in the Program with Pershing
and shall be the Client Fee for the first calendar month (or part thereof) in which the client
participates in the Program. The initial Client Fee for any partial calendar month shall be prorated
based on the number of calendar days in the partial month. Thereafter, the Client Fee shall be
calculated at the beginning of each calendar month based on the value of Program Assets on the
last business day of the prior calendar month.
If client invests $10,000 or more in any Program Account after the inception of a calendar month,
the Client Fee for the additional amount for that month will be calculated and prorated as of the
day of the additional investment. If client withdraws $10,000 or more in any Program Account, a
Client Fee credit for that month will be calculated as of the day of the withdrawal and credited
back on or before the 15th of the month following the withdrawal. The Client Fee for each month
will equal (on an annualized basis) the percentage set forth in the applicable Advisor Fee
Schedule, plus the Overlay Fee and Manager Fee (as applicable) of the fair market value of the
Program Assets in the applicable category (including interest paid or accrued) as calculated on
the last business day of the previous calendar month. The Platform Manager will determine fair
market value for Client Fee calculation purposes. Partial withdrawals from the Program Account
will be eligible for a refund of fees paid in advance. Client agrees that excessive contributions or
withdrawals, as determined by Adviser in its sole discretion, can be subject to additional charges
to cover administrative costs. If a Program Account is terminated and all Program Assets are
withdrawn from the Program prior to the end of a month, the pro rata portion of the Client Fee will
be reimbursed to client.
If there is insufficient cash in the Program Account at the time the Client Fee is to be debited from
the Program Account, Adviser or Platform Manager can sell an amount of Program Assets to
generate sufficient cash to pay the Client Fee. This can create a taxable gain or tax loss for you.
B. Fee-Based Accounts
Wrap Programs and Client Fees
Our advisory services are offered as part of a wrap program. In a wrap program, you pay a fee
that is based on the market value of the assets (securities and cash) held in your account (i.e., an
asset-based fee) (“Client Fee”). The Client Fee and fee schedule applicable to an account
depends on the services and investments you choose. Changes in your portfolio holdings and/or
allocation can impact the billing rate (%). Our fee schedules are “tiered,” which means as the
value of an account’s assets reaches a new threshold (or tier), the assets above that threshold
are charged successively lower percentages.
In a wrap program, the asset-based fee includes most transaction costs and fees to a broker-
dealer that executes trades and/or holds your assets (called “custody”), and as a result wrap fees
are typically higher than non-wrap advisory fees. (In non-wrap programs, commissions are
typically charged on a trade-by-trade basis in addition to an advisory fee.) The more securities
and cash held in an advisory account, the more you will pay in fees. The nature of how we are
compensated in an advisory account can incentivize the encouragement to maintain and/or
increase the assets held in your account(s).
Other Fee-Based Account Considerations
Before investing in any of the wrap programs detailed in this Brochure, you should be aware that
these programs can cost more or less then purchasing such services separately. Asset-based
fee arrangements, when compared with regular commission-based brokerage accounts,
generally result in lower costs during periods when active trading is occurring, such as the year
an account is established. During periods when limited trading activity is taking place, such
programs can result in a higher total annual cost for transactions.
Cash and money market funds (collectively “cash”) in an MPS Program Account are included in
calculating the Client Fee. This includes, but is not limited to, cash that a client chooses to
designate as “protected” within a Program Account. Protected cash is not invested, managed nor
included in a Program Account’s model. If you plan to maintain a large amount of cash, it is
recommended that you do so in a brokerage (i.e., non-fee-based) account. It can cost you less
to hold cash in a brokerage account.
There are many factors which determine if a fee-based account would be more cost effective than
similar services purchased separately. These factors include, but are not limited to, the total cost
of transactions in a commission-based account versus the management fee charged in the wrap
program, amount of account turnover, type of securities purchased or sold, and number of
securities purchased or sold, trading discounts allowed, and your tax situation. When making
cost comparisons, you should be aware that the combination of investment advisory, custodial
and brokerage services available through these programs may not be available separately or may
require multiple accounts and fees. In either type of account, you should also be aware that any
advisory fees or commission amounts charged are in addition to the management fees and
operating expenses charged by open-end, closed-end and exchange-traded funds. To the extent
that you intend to hold fund shares for an extended period of time, it can be more economical for
you to purchase fund shares outside of a wrap fee program. Clients can also be able to purchase
mutual funds directly from the respective fund families without incurring any additional advisory
fees that may be charged by Comerica Securities. However, when purchasing or selling directly
from fund families, you may incur a front or back-end sales charge, or “load.” Funds purchased
in the wrap fee program are purchased with no sales-charge or “load.” Some open-end mutual
funds available in the Program, in addition to assessing management fees, assess a distribution
fee pursuant to section 12(b)-1 of the Investment Company Act of 1940, or an administrative or
service fee referred to as a “trail.” Such fees are included in the calculation of operating expenses
of a mutual fund and are disclosed in the fund prospectus.
When available from the fund family, Comerica Securities will typically recommend, buy and hold
a class of mutual fund shares designed for advisory accounts, as they are more advantageous to
the client. This class of mutual fund shares generally does not pay a 12b-1 service fee back to
Comerica Securities. In certain instances, because a mutual fund company does not offer
institutional class (or other non‐12b‐1 fee paying) mutual funds or does not contractually offer
them to Comerica Securities clients, mutual funds with a more expensive structure will be
selected.
Program Accounts may hold and/or add to (i.e., recommend or buy) existing fund positions that
have a more expense structure, even when lower-cost shares of the same fund are available.
Certain Separate Account Managers and Fund Strategists invest in mutual funds that have a more
expensive structure than mutual funds that are designed for advisory accounts, including mutual
funds that impose 12b-1 fees, even when lower-cost shares of the same fund are available.
If mutual fund shares designed for advisory accounts are not available or not used, the purchase
will be done with no sales charge regardless of the type of fund class share used. Additionally, if
any 12b-1 service fees are received by Comerica Securities for mutual funds held in a Program
Account, the fees are credited to the client’s advisory Program Account.
Certain mutual funds offered in these Programs impose short-term trading charges (typically 1%-
2% of the amount originally invested) for redemptions generally made within short periods of time.
These short-term charges are imposed by the funds and not by Comerica Securities. These
charges are imposed by the funds to deter “market timers” who trade actively in fund shares. You
should consider these short-term trading charges when selecting the program and/or mutual
funds in which you invest and details are available in each fund’s prospectus.
C. General Information on Other Fees Charged to Clients
The Client Fee does not cover certain charges associated with securities transactions in clients’
accounts, including:
• any dealer markups, markdowns or spreads that can be charged on transactions in
over-the-counter securities;
• costs relating to trading in certain foreign securities;
• the internal charges and fees that are imposed by investments such as mutual funds
and closed-end funds, unit investment trusts, exchange-traded funds or real estate
investment trusts such as fund operating expenses, management fees, redemption
fees, 12b-1 fees and other fees and expenses. Further information regarding charges
and fees assessed on these investments can be found in the appropriate prospectus
or offering document or other regulatory fees;
• brokerage commissions or other charges imposed by broker-dealers or entities other
than the custodian if and when trades are cleared by a broker-dealer other than
Pershing (please refer to “Trading Away and Program Client Costs” in Section I.
Brokerage Practices, 1. Best Execution Policy, for additional details);
• the charge to carry tax lot information on transferred mutual funds or other investment
vehicles, postage and handling charges, returned check charges, transfer taxes; stock
exchange fees or other fees mandated by law; and
• any brokerage commissions or other charges, including contingent deferred sales
charges (“CDSC”), imposed upon the liquidation of “in-kind assets” that are transferred
into the Program.
Clients should be aware that if they transfer assets into a Program, Comerica Securities can
liquidate such assets immediately or at a future point in time, and clients can incur a brokerage
commission or other charge, including a CDSC. Clients can also be subject to taxes when
Comerica Securities liquidates such assets. Accordingly, you should consult with your financial
and tax consultant before transferring assets into a Program.
The Client Fee does not cover certain custodial fees that can be charged to clients by the
custodian. This includes, for example, reorganization and bond redemption fees. Clients can also
be charged for specific account services, such as account transfers, electronic fund and wire
transfer charges, and for certain optional services elected by clients. Similarly, the Client Fee
does not cover certain non-brokerage-related fees, such as, annual maintenance and termination
fees. In addition, for a limited number of services provided by our custodian, if and when
applicable, your account will be charged a fee that is higher than the fee assessed by the
custodian. Comerica Securities retains the difference between the custodial fee and what you
are charged. This includes, for example, outgoing and manual account transfer fees.
Also, some mutual funds assess redemption fees to investors upon the short-term sale of their
funds. Depending on the particular mutual fund, this includes sales for rebalancing purposes.
Please see the prospectus for the specific mutual fund for detailed information regarding such
fees. Pershing can charge short-term trading charges for funds that are part of Pershing’s
FundVest Platform. FundVest no-load funds charge 12b-1 fees. Comerica Securities receives
a waiver of ticket charges on eligible no-load mutual fund and exchange-traded fund (collectively,
“Funds”) transactions. This waiver creates a conflict to place clients in programs or strategies
that invest in participating Funds. To address this, Comerica Securities does not endorse one
program, strategy or Fund over another with our Financial Consultants. In addition, Financial
Consultants do not receive a financial incentive to recommend one Fund over another. All 12b-1
fees received by Comerica Securities for FundVest Funds held in a Program Account are credited
to the client’s advisory Program Account. The Firm does not receive any other service fees, or
revenue sharing for Funds that are part of the FundVest Program.
In addition, a client can incur redemption fees, when the portfolio manager to an investment
strategy determines that it is in the client’s overall interest, in conjunction with the stated goals of
the investment strategy, to divest from certain investments prior to the expiration of any minimum
holding period that applies. Depending on the length of the redemption period, the particular
investment strategy and/or market circumstances, a portfolio manager may be able to minimize
any redemption fees when, in the portfolio manager’s discretion, it is reasonable to allow a client
to remain invested in an investment until expiration of any minimum holding period.
Any fees you pay reduce the overall value of and net performance of your Program Account. You
should consider the aggregate costs and expenses of investment advisory services and products
as a whole.
D. Recommending Wrap Fee Programs
Financial Consultants can have a financial incentive to recommend a fee-based advisory program
to a client rather than a client paying for investment advisory services, brokerage, performance
reporting and other services separately. A portion of the advisory fee is paid to your Financial
Consultant, which can be more than they would receive under an alternative program or if you
paid for these services separately. Therefore, your Financial Consultant may have a financial
incentive to recommend a particular account program over another. Financial Consultants do not
receive a financial incentive to recommend one mutual fund over another but transactional (i.e.,
non-advisory) compensation structures vary by product type and Financial Consultants receive
higher compensation for certain product types or programs.
E. Financial Consultant Additional Sources of Compensation
Forgivable Loans
From time to time, Comerica Securities adds new associated persons who generally conduct
business as both an investment adviser representative of the Firm’s investment adviser and as a
registered representative of its broker-dealer (hereafter, collectively “Financial Consultant” or
“FC”). To assist these new Financial Consultants as they transition to Comerica Securities, the
Firm pays the FC a salary in the form of a loan (also referred to as a “draw”). The salary payments
are the sum of a fixed dollar amount plus a dollar amount based on percentage of revenue earned
during the payroll period.
While the specific terms for each draw can differ, for newly hired FCs, they are generally
structured as a combination of forgivable and non-forgivable loans, which have production- and/or
asset-based components (collectively, the “components”). Loans are typically forgivable without
condition during the first two years of an FC’s tenure. The amount of the forgivable draw, if any,
payable during years 3 through 5 is typically reduced or fully eliminated depending on whether
the FC met certain goals based on one or both components during year 1 and each year
thereafter, as applicable, and as follows:
• With a production-based component, if an FC meets or exceeds a certain pre-determined
sales revenue target (e.g., total of commissions, sales credits, markups/downs, and fees
earned during the period), the forgivable draw, if any, for the applicable period will be at a
higher amount than if the sales revenue target was not met. Production-based goals
present a conflict of interest in that they incentivize an FC to recommend that clients invest
using those products or services that provide the greatest amount of revenue to Comerica
Securities and themselves, rather than lower-cost products, when available, that pay less
or no revenue to the Firm.
• With an asset-based component, if an FC meets or exceeds a certain pre-determined
dollar target for new assets, generally excluding money market funds, brough to the Firm,
the forgivable draw, if any, for the applicable period will be a higher amount than if the
asset target was not met. Asset-based goals present a conflict of interest in that a FC has
an incentive to recommend that clients transfer their accounts, including securities
holdings and cash to Comerica Securities, rather than maintain them at their current firm.
The products and services offered by Comerica Securities, including its fee and
commission schedules, will differ in varying degrees from those available, or that the client
is currently invested in, at their present firm. The exclusion of money market funds, if
applicable to a particular FC agreement, creates an incentive for the FC to recommend
alternate investment products, which may have different benefits, features, costs and risks
than a money market fund. Account transfers may result in the client incurring
administrative or custodial fees (e.g., account transfer or termination fees) and require the
liquidation of certain holdings for an account to be transferred. This could result in, for
example, reportable tax events and/or additional fees or commissions being incurred by
the client.
Non-Forgivable Loans
Once a forgivable loan term has passed, typically no later than 2 years after the FC’s employment
start date, for the remainder of their career with Comerica Securities, the draw received, if any, is
in the form of a non-forgivable loan plus a percentage of revenue earned. A non-forgivable loan
presents a conflict of interest that in the event of an FC’s separation from the Firm, the FC shall
be required to repay Comerica Securities for all outstanding draw amounts to the extent not fully
recovered against commissions credited as of their employment end date. This creates an
incentive for an FC to recommend that clients invest using those products or services that provide
the greatest amount of revenue to Comerica Securities and themselves, rather than lower-cost
products, when available, that pay less or no revenue to the Firm.
Other Asset-Based Performance Compensation
From time to time, in addition to the above-described loan structures, the Firm will also enter into
an agreement with a newly hired FC that includes an asset-based performance bonus (“Bonus”).
While the specific terms of each Bonus will differ, the performance terms are typically structured
over a 7- to 8-year period. The Bonus, which is generally based on the FC’s current book of
business, establishes a pre-determined dollar target for new assets brought to Comerica
Securities. Similar to the Forgivable Loan, the Bonus structure will generally exclude money
market funds. The dollar target must generally be met by the end of the FC’s 5th year of
employment with the Firm. If the FC meets or exceeds the dollar target, he or she is eligible for
a cash payment based on the total amount of new assets as of the end of year 5. The Bonus is
payable, in 3 equal parts, over a multi-year period, beginning in year 6. As explained in the
Forgivable Loan section (above), asset-based goals and security exclusions present a conflict of
interest for the FC and Firm.
To mitigate the above-described conflicts, the Firm has policies and procedures in place regarding
account-type and investment recommendations. In addition, your FC has a fiduciary duty to put
your interest ahead of his or her own interest and ahead of the interest of the Firm. When your
FC provides investment advice regarding an account type, strategy and/or security, including
transfer of accounts and assets, he or she is required to act in your best interest.
Prior to transferring accounts and assets, or making investment decisions, clients are
strongly encouraged to review Comerica Securities’ Regulation Best Interest Disclosure
Document and its Client Relationship Summary, and to speak with their Financial
Consultant regarding the important differences between an advisory (investment adviser
representative) and a brokerage (registered representative) relationship, including the
differences in how Financial Consultants are compensated and how those compensation
arrangements create unique conflicts of interest.